Sellers searching for agency performance data need to know which platforms host the most comprehensive outcome reports. Detailed results appear in specific sections of online communities where members share campaign metrics and partnership experiences. These locations contain granular information about sales increases, advertising efficiency improvements, and timeline achievements. Sellers posting their experiences include screenshots, data tables, and month-by-month breakdowns that demonstrate actual results. Communities dedicated to Amazon selling feature extensive threads discussing My Amazon Guy customer Reddit reviews, outcome documentation.
Forum thread discussions
Reddit communities and specialized Amazon seller forums host the most detailed outcome posts. Members create threads specifically documenting their agency partnerships with complete performance histories. These posts include:
- Starting baseline metrics before agency engagement
- Monthly progression showing sales and ACoS changes
- Specific campaign types launched and their individual performance
- Budget allocations across different advertising strategies
- Final results after three, six, or twelve-month partnerships
Sellers often update these threads as partnerships progress, creating real-time documentation of outcomes. Other members ask clarifying questions about product categories, competition levels, and budget sizes, prompting original posters to share additional context. This interactive format produces comprehensive outcome records that static reviews cannot match.
Comment section details
Detailed outcomes frequently appear buried in comment sections rather than original posts. Someone might start a general thread asking about agency recommendations, then current clients respond with their specific results in replies. These comments contain valuable data because responders address particular questions about outcomes in their niche or budget range. Comment chains develop into detailed exchanges where sellers compare their results with those of others using similar agencies. One seller might mention achieving 35% ACoS, prompting another to share that they reached 28% in the same product category. These comparative discussions reveal outcome variations across different business situations.
Follow-up progress reports
Some sellers create dedicated progress report threads documenting their agency partnerships from start to current status. These ongoing posts appear as monthly or quarterly updates tracking:
- Campaign performance metrics at regular intervals
- Strategy changes implemented by agencies
- Seasonal fluctuations and how agencies adapted
- Spending adjustments and resulting outcome shifts
- Long-term trends emerging over extended partnerships
Follow-up reports provide longitudinal data showing whether initial results sustained or changed over time. Sellers note when agencies maintained momentum versus when performance plateaued. These extended timelines help others project realistic long-term expectations.
Case study posts
Experienced sellers occasionally write comprehensive case study posts detailing complete agency partnership experiences. These in-depth accounts include background about their business, why they hired an agency, what services they received, and full outcome documentation. Case studies present data in organised formats with clear before-and-after comparisons. Writers often include visual elements like charts showing sales growth curves or tables comparing metrics across quarters. These formatted presentations make outcome data easier to digest and compare against personal situations. Case study posts frequently receive high engagement, accumulating dozens of comments requesting additional details.
Review compilation threads
Some community members create compilation threads gathering agency reviews from multiple sources into a single post. These compilations organize outcome data by agency, making comparisons straightforward. Compilers request specific information from contributors, like monthly ad spend, partnership duration, and percentage-based improvements. Compilation threads standardize how outcomes get reported, allowing direct comparisons between agencies. Someone might list ten different seller experiences with an agency, each including similar data points about results achieved. This standardization reveals patterns in agency performance across various client types.
